365 Days Of Philosophy

The Tumblr For The 365 Days Of Philosophy Site

April 1st - Ethics And April Fool’s Day

April Fish

Is an April Fool’s Joke an Ethical Violation?- The New York Personal Injury Law Blog.

On April Fool’s Day, the joke can be on journalists- Michael “Clay” Carey.

Lawyer Says April Fool’s Joke Was Not an Ethics Violation- ABA Journal.

April Fool’s Day Ethics- Ethics Alarms.

Free philosophy papers for the next assignment you have due.

March 31st - Hunger Games Lesson: Dystopia Vs. Utopia

March 30th - The Future - Utopia Or Dystopia?

March 29th - Utopias - Discussions in Philosophy: Zombie Apocalypse and Robot Dystopia

March 28th - Utopias - Dr. Michio Kaku - Can Nanotechnology Create Utopias?

March 27th - Dystopias - Margaret Atwood’s The Handmaid’s Tale

Atwood The Handmaid Tale

"OfFred was a normal everyday woman with a career, a name, a life like all women have come to expect and take for granted in this age. When the Religious Right came into power, they began to put into practice their insane beliefs which strip women of their identity, their rights, their body, their very name. Women are to be called Of (whatever asshat they belong to), instead of, say Beatrix. Reproduction is an issue because all the toxins in the environment have rendered many women infertile. But if you are fertile, woe to you, you get to be a baby factory against your will, get promised to some jerk you don’t love or even like because someone deemed him important enough to breed. Oh, come on!

This book was written in 1986…” - Review by Stephanie on GoodReads, February 10th, 2012.

While the genre of the book is open to debate (Valerie Martin in the introduction of the 2006 Everyman’s Library edition, suggests it is political satire, allegory, and even “reconstructed post-print novel”), I would argue that The Handmaid’s Tale by Margaret Atwood can be seen to firmly fit within the genre of science fiction, often called “speculative fiction”. This is an attempt by writers using their imagination to project themselves into a possible future.

Corporations and zygotes are not conceptually related, but, nonetheless, the extension of personhood rights to corporations may pave the way for the extension of personhood rights to zygotes. The latter action would, of course, limit the autonomy and reproductive rights of real persons, namely women. - Protect Zygotes and Corporations; Piss on Women, CFI, by Ronald A. Lindsay.

Within science fiction, you can see different kinds of novels: technology based, space, novels that explore society on earth as it might be in the future, and so on. Some of the more famous examples of speculative fiction include Huxley’s Brave New World, or Orwell’s Nineteen Eighty-Four. Sociologically speculative stories usually propose an argument about what are contemporary (not fictional) issues. The Handmaid’s Tale is one of these kinds of stories; it’s the author’s creation of an imagined society which grows out of our own, and represents potential events in the world as we know it.

Appearing of MSNBC with Andrea Mitchell today, Foster Friess, the main donor to the Super PAC backing Rick Santorum’s presidential bid, dismissed the controversy surrounding President Obama’s new birth control rule by suggesting that women should just keep their legs shut. - Santorum Sugar Daddy Foster Friess Gives ‘Gals’ Contraception Advice: Put An Aspirin Between Your Knees, Alex Seitz-Wald, Think Progress.org, Feb 16, 2012.

Her fault, her fault, her fault, we chant in unison. Who led them on? Aunt Helena beams, pleased with us. She did. She did. She did. Why did God allow such a terrible thing to happen? Teach her a lesson. Teach her a lesson. Teach her a lesson. - The Handmaid’s Tale, p. 82.

The Handmaid’s Tale also falls into a sub-genre within speculative fiction, one with philosophical and literary antecedents. It is a dystopian novel: fiction that sets up for our contemplation an imagined world, not an ideal one - one in which the worst things that could happen have come to pass. Atwood does something similar to what Orwell and Huxley have done: demonstrating through her work how human society can go wrong.

The influence of earlier dystopian works like those of Swift’s Gulliver’s Travels or Butler’s Erehwon, or even Huxley’s Brave New World is open to discussion (I could point out comparisons between the segregation in Gilead and Brave New World’s World State) - but it can be said that Atwood is consciously working within a generic tradition. It’s not necessary to have read More, Huxley or Orwell to engage with The Handmaid’s Tale, but a knowledge of dystopian texts does enrich the debate of which this book is a part.

The ultrasound legislation would constitute an unprecedented government mandate to insert vaginal ultrasonic probes into women as part of a state-ordered effort to dissuade them from terminating pregnancies, legislative opponents noted.

…”We hear the same song over there. The very tragic human notes that are often touched upon involve extreme examples,” said [Todd] Gilbert, R-Shenandoah. “But in the vast majority of these cases, these are matters of lifestyle convenience.”Virginia House getting all up in your vagina, Daily Kos, February 15th, 2012.

Religious discourse is used within the novel as a form of social conformity - marginalising women’s place in society in both subtle and overt ways - and naturalises the patriarchy. Women can also act in collusion with men against other non-privileged women, to benefit their own standing in society; Serena Joy, who worked as an Evangelical singer, promoted the very same system that eventually resulted in her being house-bound, complicit and resentful. Offred’s atittudes reflect a woman who “had it all”, who looked complacently at the groups that represented women’s rights and sees her mother as an aging women’s rights activist whose efforts were “over the top”.

The Republic of Gilead is a clear warning for complacency of such women in society to accept their independence and equality without question - as predicted by Offred’s mother and by Moira, who eventually succumbed to the Republic of Gilead as a member of the Jezabel’s club (“…What I hear in her voice is indifference, a lack of volition." p.284).

Set in Cambridge, Massachusetts (the Wall that is used for hanging executed bodies is in Harvard University), this is the story of a destabilised country, dying from radiation poisoning, which takes drastic steps to secure the population of male genes. Women’s biological function is privileged, but as a result, women become marginalised as individuals - as the prime aim is to find healthy, fertile women who can produce children for those ruling class of men in position of power and influence. To me, The Handmaid’s Tale is indeed a dystopian novel, a warning - if society refuses to “act upon” changes enacted by dominant groups with strong ideologies, a totalitarian state like Gilead could be the devastating result.

As all historians know, the past is a great darkness, and filled with echoes. Voices may reach us from it; but what they say to us is imbued with the obscurity of the matrix out of which they come; and try as we may, we cannot always decipher them precisely in the clearer light of our own day. Are there any questions? - From the partial transcript of Problems of Authentication in Reference To The Handmaid’s Tale - Professor James Darcy Pieixoto (The Handmaid’s Tale, p.324).

March 26th - Utopias - Cloud Atlas

New York Review of Books - Cloud Atlas’s Theory of Everything by Emily Eakin.

The Moral Minefield - Cloud Atlas by David Mitchell: A Philosophical and Ethical Book Review by Brian Green.

David Mitchell’s Cloud Atlas : “revolutionary or gimmicky?” - Masters Thesis by Sarah-Jane Johnston Ellis.

March 25th - Introduction To Utopias And Dystopias

March 23rd - 365 Days Of Philosophy Podcast - Lecture By A.C Grayling On Rights

AC Grayling 365

Welcome to the third episode of the 365 Days of Philosophy podcast, hosted by Kylie Sturgess. This episode is for March, 2013. This is a Professor AC Grayling lecture recorded a few years back at ChristChurch Grammar school, Perth, on the concept of rights.

Professor Grayling has lectured in philosophy at St Anne’s College, Oxford, before taking up a post in 1991 at Birkbeck, University of London, where in 1998 he became reader in philosophy, and in 2005 professor. He resigned from Birkbeck in June 2011 to found and become the first master of New College of the Humanities, an independent undergraduate college in London. He is a Supernumerary Fellow of St Anne’s College, Oxford. He writes the Thinking Read column for the Barnes and Noble Review in New York, is the Editor of Online Review London, and a Contributing Editor of Prospect magazine.

Thanks again to Christ Church Grammar School and the Philosophy Department, for making this available. The music you heard is “Pale Blue Dot” and “Walking In Snow With Russians” by Ice Core Scientist, whose self-titled album is available on iTunes. You can find episodes and an RSS feed at www.365DaysofPhilosophy.com. You can also subscribe via iTunes, where you can help out the show by leaving positive comments and ratings. Thanks for listening.

March 24th - An Introduction To The Philosophy Of Politics And Economics